Carbon Neutral Newtons is a carbon neutral business - Learn more about this Newtons is a carbon neutral business

How I Got Here: We Were Hit by Fake Reviews

Posted: November 17, 2026
Written by: Chris Newton

Online reviews can make or break a business, so what happens when someone tries to use them as a weapon? For Newtons, it meant a sudden wave of fake one-star reviews and a clue that led to another firm facing exactly the same problem.

Watch the video below, in which Chris Newton tells the story of the firm’s fake review attack and how it was handled.

How I Got Here: We Were Hit by Fake Reviews Transcript

So over the 17 years that we’ve been running the business, we’ve had a few challenges. Naturally, I think the biggest one that we had was our fake review attack. We had about 30 one-star reviews come through in an afternoon. Now, these reviews were fake and they said everything bad that you could think to say about a business.

When I was searching the Google Maps link on one of these fake reviews, I saw a pin with another firm, looked at this other firm, went on their website and saw that they were suffering the same attack. They got in touch with us after a few days and said, we’ve been racking our brains as to what our two firms have in common.

Have you ever acted against such and such a company? We had about three clients in a dispute with what we would call a loan shark company. And we were pretty convinced that it was this company that was doing the fake reviews. But I spoke to the clients and said, look, this is what’s happening.

It’s doing us real damage. We can’t cope with this. I did place them with another solicitor. The other firm said, look, they don’t rely on reviews that much. They were happy to take the clients on. So the clients were looked after. And lo and behold, as soon as we stopped acting, the fake reviews stopped.

It won’t surprise you that I am now dead focused on making sure that our true clients say online what they think about us and have a read because as you will see, it’s very good.

Get in Touch with Newtons Solicitors

Newtons Solicitors has offices throughout Yorkshire, the North East, and Cumbria, so you can access legal services in the location most convenient to you.

If your business has been targeted by fake or malicious reviews, or is facing any other dispute, please don’t hesitate to reach out to our friendly team. We’re here to give you clear, objective advice so you can protect your business and its reputation.

Additionally, watch more from Chris, including how he dealt with the firm’s first dispute and the lessons he learned from hiring the firm’s first employee here.